Review Guidelines and Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers receive a structured review form covering:

1. Relevance to journal scope
2. Originality and contribution
3. Soundness of methodology
4. Quality of data analysis
5. Logical structure and clarity
6. Adequacy of references
7. Ethical and professional integrity

Overall Recommendation Options:

• Accept without revision
• Minor revision
• Major revision
• Reject

Reviewers are required to provide constructive and detailed feedback.